PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - BREAKING NEWS: airliner missing within Egyptian FIR
Old 6th Nov 2015, 05:21
  #1303 (permalink)  
CONSO
 
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: WA STATE
Age: 78
Posts: 0
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Question FWIW re HS breaking off

A little F= ma issue.

1) IF we assume the tail breaking off at frame forward of PB as an initial failure, then that would leave both HS and VS and Rudder plus APU as a unit.

2) IMO- Even IF at 400 plus mph the HS turned flat side to direction of travel, to develop enough force to rip both off at skin line would require a much higher unit mass traveling in the vector direction of travel to provide enough opposing force to break off HS

3) But IF 1) is not true ( meaning breaking off ***after/during *** breaking of HS ), then the mass- momentum of the whole plane forward of the break at the frame ahead of the PB, the resultant mass-momentum would be more than adequate to provide enough reaction/opposing force available to allow the HS to break cleanly at the skin line and the tail parts following a bit later

Keep in mind the time differences involved are very small re cause and effect and what happened first.

That being said- it is MY opinion that the initiating event was the flipping up of the HS- as the result of a) structural failure of jackscrew in some manner and b) reason for failure unknown at this time- but well place explosive is NOT excluded.
CONSO is offline