It really is no longer important what the flight crew did on the night, what 4 Corners clearly showed was the physical and emotional deterioration of Karen Casey, who 4 Corners rightly stated was the real hero of the story. Despite what the law technically is she should have been granted an ex-gratia payment by Pel-Air in recognition of what she had done. Even Dominic James looked done in by the whole deal but he at least was physically spared. I hope the judge rules in her favour but of course there will be appeals and more appeals until the money runs out.