PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - CNN Reports FEDEX crash in Tokyo
View Single Post
Old 29th Mar 2009, 03:49
  #318 (permalink)  
muduckace
Registered User **
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: USA
Age: 49
Posts: 480
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
No more handling differences in the MD11 vs MD10 than you would find with the 727-200 vs 727-100 or the DC8-55 vs DC8-63.
The DC-10/ MD-10 are the the same airframe with the same flight control surfaces, the same empty/gross weight stats., the exact same aerodynamic properties.

The MD-11 is dramaticaly different. Don't get me wrong I love the MD-11 but it is a completely different machine. The MD-10 has the same engines as the DC-10's (not FADEC), The same flight control surfaces and empty weight more or less.

The MD-11 was designed for efficiency at altitude, more efficient thrust less drag (small tail being the largest change for efficiency).

This is the MAJOR question posed to it's safety values. I still maintain that it is just as safe as the DC-10 given the driver respects and understands it's limitations.

I have been intimate with both airframes for more than 11 years.

You can not compare the DC-8-50 and -60 series as a relevant comparason, the technology and aggresive improvements do not compare at all. All DC-8's land like pancakes, heavy structure, airframe weight and aerodymic cleanliness was not a significant factor only size to increase revenue.... It is the only thing that the MD-11 shares with the DC-8/super-8 and the MD-11. Same goes for the 727.

Bottom line, the MD-11 has different flight chararistics than the MD/DC-10. Less Drag, more thrust and a smaller margine for error especially at slow speeds. When she is lite she is also much more difficult to slow down in decent but she climbs with much respect.
muduckace is offline