Mr Purdey,
of the two possibilities, which on was it? After all, the verdict makes it clear that there is absolutely no doubt whatsoever, so one should easily be able to say which one it is (complete with supporting evidence, of course).
The fact that there are two possibilities is, in itself, enough to undermine the verdict.
14th anniversary coming up in just under a week. I hope that Mr Browne makes a decision soon.
Regards, as always.
Brian
"Justice has no expiry date" - John Cook