Handsolo, thanks for the advice i'll return to the books asap! However with due respect I think you are missing my point, which in fairness may well be due to a lack of ability on my part to convey it. The theme I have been trying to stick to is that we dont know what actually happenned and apart from sensationalist views/opinions are no closer to knowing. Therefore to try the accused in a kangaroo court of their peers with no independent and unbiased information is wrong and unprofessional. It is no different to reading an article (pretty much any article) in the Daily Mail and not only believeing it 100% but using that to back up ones arguements.
This thread seems to have split into those that see this as a question of airmanship on the part of the IB crew and those like myself that think this is a highly inappropiate place and method of raising views on flight safety.