Georgemorris is allowed to have a view, and PPRuNe will respect that.
But, you, GM, are so way off target you need zeroing. The only way I can suggest you get seen to as soon as possible is for your to read from the start what this thread is about. It will take you a long time. There is another one, identical in subject, but in the archives of PPRuNe. You perhaps need to read all that has been written over all these many many years.
The simplicity you have chosen in your first post is, if it were not so serious, hysterical. Perhaps even in more than one sense. The premise you use isn't even close.
However, when you have had a good read and then respect the views of some very senior officers, engineers, Chinooks pilots and people who are well able to offer definitive views on the subject, and please recognise that they are not just merely familiar with it, you WILL change your mind.
In this instance you also need to understand that under the regulations - written by the Royal Air Force - is that gross negligence cannot be levelled at the two pilots in this tragic accident unless there is "absolutely no doubt whatsoever." Now read on if you will.
I might also add that it was a House of Lords select committee who agreed that the decision of gross negligence against the pilots, by two Air Marshalls, was wrong.
That is what this campaign, led by super people is all about. Changing the wrong the AM's did and giving back the good names of Flt Lt's Cook and Tapper.
No more hypothetical issues concerning cars please. This is planet earth! No doubt whatsoever!!