DHC6tropics, #3633
Without context none of these ‘predetermined’ measures can rate airmanship.
Experience might be judged according to what has been done (past), but this cannot be reliable projected for the use, the application of that experience in some future event. Who judges, you or an external observer.
Airmanship is not a quantity, at best it’s a rating, a term, something which can be used in conversation because it impossible to deal with these qualities in any other way.
Context, hindsight, and the human condition.