Originally Posted by
Albino
No it isn't.
AFAIK
MCAS will operate regardless of the control column cutout switches.
It will not operate against the control column TRIM switches, or if the stab trim switches are cutout.
This is my understanding also, based on the schematic posted before:
737MAX Stab Trim architecture
When MCAS is engaged, control column "extreme deflection" towards pull will NOT disable MCAS trim down, but it will NOT disable your thumb switch trim up either, so you still win.
In other words, this battle will not be affected by too much pull.