PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Spectators Balcony (Spotters Corner) (https://www.pprune.org/spectators-balcony-spotters-corner-52/)
-   -   Bilbao crosswind landings on a windy day! (https://www.pprune.org/spectators-balcony-spotters-corner/483814-bilbao-crosswind-landings-windy-day.html)

tartare 27th Apr 2012 00:03

Bilbao crosswind landings on a windy day!
 
Great footage of cross wind landings at Bilbao:

BBC News - High winds shake planes landing in Bilbao, Spain

At least one overshoot - and some very squirrelly landings - including what looks like a 737 yawing after touchdown.
Having never flown there - is this airport known for tricky crosswinds or was this just unusual WX conditions?

Loose rivets 27th Apr 2012 00:13

Just that touch of wing down seemed to instantly stabilize the last one. Well, to the point of being containable. Pity engines and big flaps stop us standing on the top rudder these days. ;)

tartare 27th Apr 2012 00:28

Sorry rivets - don't understand... please explain? :)
Although I only fly lighties - those did look like `interesting' landings - even for big, hairy chested jet pilots...

Acklington 27th Apr 2012 10:49

Bilbao landings
 

Just interested in what you pilots thought of these

Pilotinmydreams 27th Apr 2012 11:00

All in a days work
 
Not sure if this was the right forum so I understand if it's moved.

Just saw this on BBC website. May be all in a days work for you but looks bloody scary to me and just makes me thankful we have a professional sitting at the pointy end

BBC News - High winds shake planes landing in Bilbao, Spain

silverhawk 27th Apr 2012 11:38

If it is within limits, that's what we are trained to do.

That is why 1 Euro fares are unsustainable, because training and safety costs money. Experience is worth rewarding.

Interesting that the only decent, stable approach was in a B737. Hmmmm pays your money and takes your choice. You get what you pay for and maybe you want to bear that in mind when choosing a carrier.

Pilotinmydreams 27th Apr 2012 11:50

Completely agree with regard experience is worth the reward. If my £30 flight to x European country costs £5 more then i'd be happy to pay it knowing there's someone with experience getting me on the black stuff in one piece

Tony Flynn 27th Apr 2012 11:51

Windy Day in Bilbao
 
Dramatic cross-wind landings in Bilbao - Video Dailymotion

Dct_Mopas 27th Apr 2012 12:03


Originally Posted by silverhawk (Post 7159064)
Interesting that the only decent, stable approach was in a B737. Hmmmm pays your money and takes your choice. You get what you pay for and maybe you want to bear that in mind when choosing a carrier.

I didnt see a single 737 in that video, a couple of A320's yes. Great video though

lomapaseo 27th Apr 2012 12:30


You get what you pay for and maybe you want to bear that in mind when choosing a carrier
That's about as helpful advice as suggesting that you wait until three back-to-back crashes before taking your next trip

John-Q depends on experts in the regulator establishment to assess and control safety. If you expect him to do it by innuenedo and rumour he will get so mixed up that he simply won't fly at all ... can you say

redundunancies

TSR2 27th Apr 2012 18:47

Have you noticed that in the second and third landing, the aircraft passing overhead is not the aircraft that is landing. Look at the location of the engines.

i_like_tea 27th Apr 2012 19:55

Looks like a tough day out, a few of my friends had winds head and go arounds leading to diversions.

The last aircraft isn't a 737 though!

Very good to see the rejected landing too, and that they didn't try and continue it. Bravo!

ZOOKER 27th Apr 2012 20:46

Funny how one group of 'professionals', (journalists and cameramen), leech off another group of professionals, (pilots, air-men, and ladies, of course).
Yet, the former, and their 'editors', cannot even be *rsed to get the continuity right. :=
Pathetic.

mary meagher 27th Apr 2012 21:28

challenging conditions at Loiu Airport, Bilbao, Spain
 
BBC this evening with some interesting film of wild winds at Bilbao, pilots have to earn their pesos landing in galloping crosswinds....

rocket66 27th Apr 2012 21:34

Call me odd but why would the skippers of those jets attempt to land in winds like that more than once? Its clear to me that it was a bit risky for the first attempt let alone to try again.

750k 27th Apr 2012 21:54

Strange concept Rocket, I have adopted a policy of trying to keep the aircraft and myself intact, regardless of what or who is behind me!

mini 27th Apr 2012 22:53

I haven't seen the BBC coverage but CNN were sensationalising this with accelerated video footage of high yaw rate landings and a few FJ climb rate GAs.

I'd guess it was sporty but no doubt all lived... :rolleyes:

McGoonagall 27th Apr 2012 23:22

I did watch this earlier and the final landing looked an absolute beauty.

:ok::ok:

framer 28th Apr 2012 00:30


If you were a freighter with nothing but the freight to lose go for it but when your carrying 100 plus pax you should have more in mind I reckon
Would be an interesting industry if we applied that theory. Freighters and turbo props would operate in hairy conditions, jets with 100 pax would operate in more favourable conditions, and 747's and A380's would only fly with a high cloud base and light winds......

rocket66 28th Apr 2012 05:01

Sorry folks, just re-read my post. What I mean is, pax comfort and safety is something that would be high on my list, my guess is the pax in the back would have been ****ting themselves. :eek:

If you were say a freighter, and were confident that in similar conditions you could land you might want to give it a go.


Rocket


All times are GMT. The time now is 17:09.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.