121.5 UK pilot crass comment
Thread Starter
121.5 UK pilot crass comment
Yesterday as I monitored 121.5 as we entered the London FIR, I heard a student pilot who was genuinely unsure of their position, being talked down and steered toward their nearest airfield. The weather in the area was VFR but likely marginal in places due to haze and showers, it was therefore very reassuring to hear such professionalism and a calm voice from the Controller who was guiding said pilot to safety.
What got my goat was the crass comment from an English voice wishing the lost pilot "good luck" in the most inappropriate patronising tone - completely inapproiate when said pilot may well have been on the verge of drifting into IMC and the subsequent loss control.
Can't we all just be professional and resist using 121.5 unless it's imperative that we do so?
What got my goat was the crass comment from an English voice wishing the lost pilot "good luck" in the most inappropriate patronising tone - completely inapproiate when said pilot may well have been on the verge of drifting into IMC and the subsequent loss control.
Can't we all just be professional and resist using 121.5 unless it's imperative that we do so?
Last edited by JOSHUA; 1st Oct 2017 at 18:08.
Join Date: Dec 2014
Location: Midlands
Posts: 128
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Agreed, nothing like some pompous, patronising drivel to further load up a stressed situation.
Many years ago I had a bit of "Navigational Difficulties" and Heathrow Director got me back on the right track in a calm and helpful manner.
Many years ago I had a bit of "Navigational Difficulties" and Heathrow Director got me back on the right track in a calm and helpful manner.
Join Date: Jun 2017
Location: UK / FIN
Posts: 43
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Long time ago, early 90's, i was working for GA training company as a fitter. One of my duties was perform some company internal flights like ferry aircrafts to another airfield for bigger maint etc etc. (not payed for that, but got free hours)
On that time owner was expanding his fleet and i was assigned to collect one C172 from another nearby airfield. (it came from USA in container and assembled on another company)
As said, i was young and fresh pilot. On that flight i loose COM, can TX but not receive.
Remember what was told during training, and finally did my smooth join to home airfield quite busy circuit. After landing, and during circuit TWR guides me with signal lights.
Everything went ok and after landing guy from ATC came to me and said: well done boy, everything went like book says. And that ATC guy was known to be very strict, not nasty, but very strict.
I felt very good after that, not because success but knowing there is professional people behind microphone.
On that time owner was expanding his fleet and i was assigned to collect one C172 from another nearby airfield. (it came from USA in container and assembled on another company)
As said, i was young and fresh pilot. On that flight i loose COM, can TX but not receive.
Remember what was told during training, and finally did my smooth join to home airfield quite busy circuit. After landing, and during circuit TWR guides me with signal lights.
Everything went ok and after landing guy from ATC came to me and said: well done boy, everything went like book says. And that ATC guy was known to be very strict, not nasty, but very strict.
I felt very good after that, not because success but knowing there is professional people behind microphone.
Yesterday as I monitored 121.5 as we entered the London FIR, I heard a student pilot who was genuinely unsure of their position, being talked down and steered toward their nearest airfield. The weather in the area was VFR but likely marginal in places due to haze and showers, it was therefore very reassuring to hear such professionalism and a calm voice from the Controller who was guiding said pilot to safety.
What got my goat was the crass comment from an English voice wishing the lost pilot "good luck" in the most inappropriate patronising tone - completely inapproiate when said pilot may well have been on the verge of drifting into IMC and the subsequent loss control.
Can't we all just be professional and resist using 121.5 unless it's imperative that we do so?
What got my goat was the crass comment from an English voice wishing the lost pilot "good luck" in the most inappropriate patronising tone - completely inapproiate when said pilot may well have been on the verge of drifting into IMC and the subsequent loss control.
Can't we all just be professional and resist using 121.5 unless it's imperative that we do so?
At this point some smug **** in an air-conditioned airliner cruising at FL350 butted in and made a sneering comment along the lines that my ops department would have a lot to say to me when I landed..
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Hotel Gypsy
Posts: 2,821
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I was at Dubai International the other week in a light piston twin. All the biggies were departing from a set of intersections some 1500ft down the runway (12R) and the rest of us had to go with the taxi pattern. When my turn finally came, ATC (who are brilliant at DXB) gave me an enter-backtrack. Cue snide comment from an Emirates 777/380 - "Is there a performance issue?". Quick as a flash, the controller came back with a "Some people should remember where they came from. Never heard of wake turbulence, Emirates 123?"
A beautiful moment.
A beautiful moment.
Join Date: Jan 2017
Location: orlando
Posts: 22
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I was at Dubai International the other week in a light piston twin. All the biggies were departing from a set of intersections some 1500ft down the runway (12R) and the rest of us had to go with the taxi pattern. When my turn finally came, ATC (who are brilliant at DXB) gave me an enter-backtrack. Cue snide comment from an Emirates 777/380 - "Is there a performance issue?". Quick as a flash, the controller came back with a "Some people should remember where they came from. Never heard of wake turbulence, Emirates 123?"
A beautiful moment.
A beautiful moment.
It wasn't "THE" emirates 123 was it?
As they say, the 3 most useless things to an aviator:
Runway behind
Fuel in bowser
Altitude above
Totally agree about the abuse of the emergency frequency being very unprofessional.
Last edited by John_Reid; 7th Oct 2017 at 01:07.
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Dubai - sand land.
Age: 55
Posts: 2,831
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Cows getting Bigger
Cue snide comment from an Emirates 777/380 - "Is there a performance issue?
Originally Posted by Sciolistes
British accent perchance
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: United Kingdom
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts