Air India bashing - gone too far?
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: At home
Posts: 12
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Air India bashing - gone too far?
From this morning's Ney York Times:
When Bob Haygooni paid a midflight visit to a cockpit at his new employer, Air India, he was shocked. The pilots, he said, had completely covered the windows with newspaper to keep out the sun.
“All you had in the cockpit was this yellowish glow, as the light permeated the newspaper,” Mr. Haygooni recalled, saying it was a visibility hazard he had never seen before in 30 years of flying.
But “this was a normal thing at Air India,” said Mr. Haygooni, a former United Airlines pilot who flew for the Indian airline for 16 months.
"Visibility Hazard"??? I assume "midflight" means they were at cruising level, IFR, NOT VFR. Don't know about you, but when that big fire ball shines through the windows with very little atmosphere to filter it, I block it with whatever I have, turn on WX radar and peek out from time to time. I am also not aware of any requirement to be on the lookout while flying IFR. I love my job, but skin cancer was not part of my deal.
As for Air India, I guess they have their plate full without this dramatization.
When Bob Haygooni paid a midflight visit to a cockpit at his new employer, Air India, he was shocked. The pilots, he said, had completely covered the windows with newspaper to keep out the sun.
“All you had in the cockpit was this yellowish glow, as the light permeated the newspaper,” Mr. Haygooni recalled, saying it was a visibility hazard he had never seen before in 30 years of flying.
But “this was a normal thing at Air India,” said Mr. Haygooni, a former United Airlines pilot who flew for the Indian airline for 16 months.
"Visibility Hazard"??? I assume "midflight" means they were at cruising level, IFR, NOT VFR. Don't know about you, but when that big fire ball shines through the windows with very little atmosphere to filter it, I block it with whatever I have, turn on WX radar and peek out from time to time. I am also not aware of any requirement to be on the lookout while flying IFR. I love my job, but skin cancer was not part of my deal.
As for Air India, I guess they have their plate full without this dramatization.
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: -11`
Posts: 308
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Amos, you must be working for Air India or something?
Have you haver heard of "see and avoid"? Also when flying IFR you have the direct responsibility to watch out for other traffic.
And what does skincancer have to do with this? If the sun is low over the horizon, its rays actually travel further through our protective atmosphere....
Have you haver heard of "see and avoid"? Also when flying IFR you have the direct responsibility to watch out for other traffic.
And what does skincancer have to do with this? If the sun is low over the horizon, its rays actually travel further through our protective atmosphere....
1. You can not see traffic directly into sun - well not unless you are wearing an arc welding helmet.
2. Dazzle caused by the sun reduces the ability to see traffic removed from the glare ball.
3. I have flown for the RAF and three world majors. In all of these it was common and accepted practice to place a map or other obstruction over the window in line with the sun. You ain't goin' to see anything there anyway.
p.s. It is, of course, up to the ol' man whether you use this technique or not
2. Dazzle caused by the sun reduces the ability to see traffic removed from the glare ball.
3. I have flown for the RAF and three world majors. In all of these it was common and accepted practice to place a map or other obstruction over the window in line with the sun. You ain't goin' to see anything there anyway.
p.s. It is, of course, up to the ol' man whether you use this technique or not
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: In a far better place
Posts: 2,480
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Call me old fashioned... but I like to see the other aircraft that's has penetrated my threat protection area
.
I don't know, but I think that frantically tearing down newspapers from the wind screens may prove to be rather fatal... but that's just me.
. I don't know, but I think that frantically tearing down newspapers from the wind screens may prove to be rather fatal... but that's just me.
Drain Bamaged
There is a difference between:
-Placing a map or other obstruction over the window in line with the sun.
And
-Completely covering the windows with newspaper to keep out the sun.
-Placing a map or other obstruction over the window in line with the sun.
And
-Completely covering the windows with newspaper to keep out the sun.
Join Date: May 2000
Posts: 354
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Not just confined to a third world carrier. If anyone has a copy of this months Airliner World, turn to page 37. One very large US carrier with both windscreens partially blocked during a landing. I'm assuming its not a practice autoland. Now I know flying into Sun is a pain, but I have never seen anyone obstruct the screen during landing.
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: 31000FR
Posts: 60
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There is a difference between an old Jep map shading a bit on the left side window when sitting for 10 hrs with the sun at 10 o´clock and the widespread Indian culture of covering all cockpit windows completely, effectively turning the old bird into an airborne submarine.
I have come into the cockpit of one flight while in the hold into LHR in the middle of rush hour where you could see nothing outside!
Yes, I know: IFR, TCAS, God watching over you etc., but having experienced 4 actual near misses which required avoidance maneuvering, this culture makes my p..s freeze.
Recently had a Turbulev climbing straight through my level at 12 o´clock - no TCAS.
Appalled to learn that the complacency is not confined to the sub-continent....
I have come into the cockpit of one flight while in the hold into LHR in the middle of rush hour where you could see nothing outside!
Yes, I know: IFR, TCAS, God watching over you etc., but having experienced 4 actual near misses which required avoidance maneuvering, this culture makes my p..s freeze.
Recently had a Turbulev climbing straight through my level at 12 o´clock - no TCAS.
Appalled to learn that the complacency is not confined to the sub-continent....
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: At home
Posts: 12
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
seat 0A:
I have nothing to do with Air India. However, I do have a lot of experience flying into the sun (and not only when it's "low over the horizon"). "See and avoid"? Give me a break. Must be flying Cesnas for too long. In modern radar controlled airspace, with TCAS II, you really don't need to be on a "lookout" through the windows - you will be better off looking at your ND for potential traffic hazards and peek outside ONLY when a potential conflict is near. I don't remember ATC requiring different separation when I'm in clouds or at night. On the other hand, read the statistics about pilots getting skin cancer, and you'll figure out what skin cancer has to do with it.
I have nothing to do with Air India. However, I do have a lot of experience flying into the sun (and not only when it's "low over the horizon"). "See and avoid"? Give me a break. Must be flying Cesnas for too long. In modern radar controlled airspace, with TCAS II, you really don't need to be on a "lookout" through the windows - you will be better off looking at your ND for potential traffic hazards and peek outside ONLY when a potential conflict is near. I don't remember ATC requiring different separation when I'm in clouds or at night. On the other hand, read the statistics about pilots getting skin cancer, and you'll figure out what skin cancer has to do with it.
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: SLF, living somewhere East in the West
Posts: 235
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I may put forward an educated guess here that the skin cancer rate in pilots is rather due to the increased amount of cosmic radiation (high energy gamma rays) rather than the UV light which is filtered out by first the actual windshield and than by the cool pilot's sunglasses...
As a SLF I rather prefer to fly in a plane where the pilots are able to quickly look up and see whats coming than as someone phrased it "flying submarine" or grandma's coffee parlor in the garden...
As a SLF I rather prefer to fly in a plane where the pilots are able to quickly look up and see whats coming than as someone phrased it "flying submarine" or grandma's coffee parlor in the garden...
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: SLF, living somewhere East in the West
Posts: 235
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Isn't it a difference if you are in low visibility conditions as they just occur or you voluntary create them. If you have a choice do you avoid low visibility or do you fly right into it (Yay)?
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: England
Posts: 1,955
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Of course, but in my experience you rarely, if ever, spend the entire cruise in cloud with limited visibility.
To artificially subject yourself to zero visibility is a bit daft.
Would you agree that the longer you spend not being able to see outside the chances of you twonking something are increased?
You can rely on TCAS and Radar all you like, they aren't infallible or 100% reliable. Uberlingen springs to mind.
What would you do if you were in the cruise and you had an RA out of the blue (which does happen)? Follow the TCAS commands and attempt to locate the other aircraft visually. You can't do both if you've got charts all over the place.
To artificially subject yourself to zero visibility is a bit daft.
Would you agree that the longer you spend not being able to see outside the chances of you twonking something are increased?
You can rely on TCAS and Radar all you like, they aren't infallible or 100% reliable. Uberlingen springs to mind.
What would you do if you were in the cruise and you had an RA out of the blue (which does happen)? Follow the TCAS commands and attempt to locate the other aircraft visually. You can't do both if you've got charts all over the place.
Join Date: May 2002
Location: dubai
Posts: 942
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
When I started learning aviation (still learning) the first rule of airman ship was and still is, is lookout!! How the hell can you conduct a lookout with the windscreen covered in newspapers??
Keeping out the sun I suspect is a pigmentation issue with the indigenous at AI, rather than anything else.
Keeping out the sun I suspect is a pigmentation issue with the indigenous at AI, rather than anything else.
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Playing Golf!
Age: 46
Posts: 1,037
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A Boeing report also made it very clear to Air India that the covering of the flight deck windows in flight like this was not acceptable... That is at least 3 years old now... So nothing has changed.
PT6A
PT6A
