A RAAF Mirage wheels up landing story worth reading
Thread Starter
A RAAF Mirage wheels up landing story worth reading
This remarkable story by former RAAF Mirage pilot, Nick Ford, has a flight safety lesson for all pilots -airline and general aviation - in that it is all too easy to forget to lower your landing gear when various disconcerting factors build up to affect the pilot's train of thought at a critical time.
Nick Ford did a beautifully smooth wheels up landing on Melbourne Runway 34 into 30 knot plus head wind component. His story of this landing was published by the Queensland Air Museum.
QAM - The Last Landing of Mirage A3-16
Nick Ford did a beautifully smooth wheels up landing on Melbourne Runway 34 into 30 knot plus head wind component. His story of this landing was published by the Queensland Air Museum.
QAM - The Last Landing of Mirage A3-16
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Often in Jersey, but mainly in the past.
Age: 79
Posts: 7,808
Received 135 Likes
on
63 Posts
A very interesting read - thanks for posting.
Interesting how memory can play tricks. I'm pretty sure that 250 below 10 wasn't mandated in Oz until much later after this event. Also much of the initial controlling would have been by RAAF controllers, who had their own airspace in those days ( the wedge containing Laverton, Avalon and beyond to the southwest and above F190 within 40NM Melbourne). I doubt also the practice of a full rectangular circuit every time. The light aircraft lane still exists and doesn't seem to bother the many 34 arrivals.
Join Date: Apr 1998
Location: Mesopotamos
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
A thoroughly enjoyable read that illustrates just how such incidents can happen.
I sense that the author still harbours a bit of guilt for supposedly being responsible for writing off a Mirage. If only he knew that the reason we ended up with the Mirages was because it was the only way the French could balance the trade for $150m of wheat which they owed us. Writing off the Mirage by its makers would have meant wiping off another few million on a replacement.
I sense that the author still harbours a bit of guilt for supposedly being responsible for writing off a Mirage. If only he knew that the reason we ended up with the Mirages was because it was the only way the French could balance the trade for $150m of wheat which they owed us. Writing off the Mirage by its makers would have meant wiping off another few million on a replacement.
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: Melbourne
Age: 72
Posts: 774
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The light aircraft lane still exists and doesn't seem to bother the many 34 arrivals.
Well actually it doesn't. The lane was a narrow corridor between the Melbourne and Laverton control zones. When Laverton closed, the lane went. Check the Melbourne VTC. ML RWY 34 arrivals are protected by the CTA steps.
Well actually it doesn't. The lane was a narrow corridor between the Melbourne and Laverton control zones. When Laverton closed, the lane went. Check the Melbourne VTC. ML RWY 34 arrivals are protected by the CTA steps.
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Clipperton island
Posts: 364
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
" operating within 50 nm of Tullamarine, and below 10,000 feet, CAA required all aircraft to fly under 250 knots to help air traffic controllers manage aircraft movements "
What a bunch of turists ! who was in charge ? is the AF in that country in a position of submission in front of civilian ATC ?
" by flying below 250 knots the undercarriage warning light was on most of the time and, after a very short time of operating out of Avalon, Mirage pilots learnt to ignore it. In my accident flight, shortly after take-off when I cut the afterburner and pulled back power to stay below 250 knots, the undercarriage warning light came on and probably remained flashing for the whole of my sortie. I don’t know for sure because, like all other Mirage pilots operating in Melbourne, I had learnt to ignore this warning light."
Incredible !
Also how many times does it say "the French tale" ? because obviously the French had to be blamed for that.... trying to find an excuse maybe ?
Having been a Mirage III pilot for years, I'm more than confused about what he has been writing down. What he says about the way RAAF and Armée de l'air were supposed to land the aircraft differently is complete BS.
Many years ago Singapore had some Israeli pilots in exchange. After a couple of DACT with the RAAF Mirages of Butterworth (Penang, for those who don't remember) they were completely astonished by their performance - in a bad way.
What a bunch of turists ! who was in charge ? is the AF in that country in a position of submission in front of civilian ATC ?
" by flying below 250 knots the undercarriage warning light was on most of the time and, after a very short time of operating out of Avalon, Mirage pilots learnt to ignore it. In my accident flight, shortly after take-off when I cut the afterburner and pulled back power to stay below 250 knots, the undercarriage warning light came on and probably remained flashing for the whole of my sortie. I don’t know for sure because, like all other Mirage pilots operating in Melbourne, I had learnt to ignore this warning light."
Incredible !
Also how many times does it say "the French tale" ? because obviously the French had to be blamed for that.... trying to find an excuse maybe ?
Having been a Mirage III pilot for years, I'm more than confused about what he has been writing down. What he says about the way RAAF and Armée de l'air were supposed to land the aircraft differently is complete BS.
Many years ago Singapore had some Israeli pilots in exchange. After a couple of DACT with the RAAF Mirages of Butterworth (Penang, for those who don't remember) they were completely astonished by their performance - in a bad way.
SkyGod
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: Palm Coast, Florida, USA
Age: 67
Posts: 1,542
Likes: 0
Received 10 Likes
on
1 Post
Ouch. Must be rough for a Right Stuff ego to make a student pilot mistake.
There is always a bunch of other factors to use for diluting the blame, ATC would be a good one.
If I was the Mirage driver I would have kept a low profile and chalked it up to bad luck or a bad day instead of writing a 3 page essay.
There is always a bunch of other factors to use for diluting the blame, ATC would be a good one.
If I was the Mirage driver I would have kept a low profile and chalked it up to bad luck or a bad day instead of writing a 3 page essay.
fujii: As I said, "Interesting how memory can play tricks"
Even I can get things wrong.
I stand by the fact that there was no 250 below 10 at that time. As for the rest?
Even I can get things wrong.
I stand by the fact that there was no 250 below 10 at that time. As for the rest?
Thread Starter
Further to my OP. In the late Sixties I was a QFI at 34 Squadron on Viscounts among other types. There was a HQ Operations Command flight safety conference to be held at Williamtown and I was required to attend.
Rang up the then CO of the Mirage unit at Williamtown who was on our initial aircrew intake course at Point Cook many years earlier. Jim Treadwell, a lovely bloke.
"Hey Jim - Centaurus here. I'm flying to Willy for the OPCOM flight safety conference next week. I'll give you a couple of circuits in the Viscount if you can give me a ride in the dual Mirage." Jim was happy with that plan and I duly arrived in the 34 Squadron Viscount which we used as a taxi hack under the guise of continuation training.
Jim was the pilot of the Mirage and I was strapped into the back seat. I felt immediate claustrophobia as an airman fastened numerous restraining straps around my body and legs and by then I almost elected to stop the airman and say I want to get out of here now.
Jim was in the front seat and I didn't want to embarrass him so I stayed. When Jim then briefed me about various red warning light scenarios requiring immediate ejection, I was quite frankly really scared and deeply regretted my gung-ho phone call to Jim about swopping a Viscount ride for a Mirage ride.
We got airborne and eventually went through the sound barrier for a few seconds with Jim kindly letting me fly through Mach One so I could boast about it once safely on the ground.
He then joined for a PFL (practice forced landing) from around 20,000 ft over Williamtown. I asked him over the intercom what was his planned over the fence speed for the PFL. He said we never land from a PFL but go around from around 500 feet (if my memory is correct) due high sink rate and engine spool up time.
I think we turned base around 9000 ft and remember there were no flaps on a Mirage. I think speed on final was around 180 knots and I couldn't see much from the back seat. As I said, I was tightly strapped in and feeling apprehensive about the whole thing. Jim went around as briefed, and then went back for an initial from five miles, savage break left into downwind and landed smoothly on the piano keys, much to my relief.
There was an immediate harsh deceleration after touch down and I thought Jim must have really stamped on the anchors. Not so, as it turned out. It was the drag chute operating and all I can say from memory it was like max manual braking on a 737. Jim had not started to touch the brakes yet.
After the trip I couldn't get out of the cockpit fast enough and thanked Jim for the unforgettable (to me, anyway) ride. After lunch I pre-flighted the Viscount to give Jim some circuits. But he was too busy organising the flight safety conference to accept; which was a real pity. After that little episode I had great admiration for Mirage pilots which I still have to this day. Thanks a million Jimmy Treadwell. I understand you are still around.
Rang up the then CO of the Mirage unit at Williamtown who was on our initial aircrew intake course at Point Cook many years earlier. Jim Treadwell, a lovely bloke.
"Hey Jim - Centaurus here. I'm flying to Willy for the OPCOM flight safety conference next week. I'll give you a couple of circuits in the Viscount if you can give me a ride in the dual Mirage." Jim was happy with that plan and I duly arrived in the 34 Squadron Viscount which we used as a taxi hack under the guise of continuation training.
Jim was the pilot of the Mirage and I was strapped into the back seat. I felt immediate claustrophobia as an airman fastened numerous restraining straps around my body and legs and by then I almost elected to stop the airman and say I want to get out of here now.
Jim was in the front seat and I didn't want to embarrass him so I stayed. When Jim then briefed me about various red warning light scenarios requiring immediate ejection, I was quite frankly really scared and deeply regretted my gung-ho phone call to Jim about swopping a Viscount ride for a Mirage ride.
We got airborne and eventually went through the sound barrier for a few seconds with Jim kindly letting me fly through Mach One so I could boast about it once safely on the ground.
He then joined for a PFL (practice forced landing) from around 20,000 ft over Williamtown. I asked him over the intercom what was his planned over the fence speed for the PFL. He said we never land from a PFL but go around from around 500 feet (if my memory is correct) due high sink rate and engine spool up time.
I think we turned base around 9000 ft and remember there were no flaps on a Mirage. I think speed on final was around 180 knots and I couldn't see much from the back seat. As I said, I was tightly strapped in and feeling apprehensive about the whole thing. Jim went around as briefed, and then went back for an initial from five miles, savage break left into downwind and landed smoothly on the piano keys, much to my relief.
There was an immediate harsh deceleration after touch down and I thought Jim must have really stamped on the anchors. Not so, as it turned out. It was the drag chute operating and all I can say from memory it was like max manual braking on a 737. Jim had not started to touch the brakes yet.
After the trip I couldn't get out of the cockpit fast enough and thanked Jim for the unforgettable (to me, anyway) ride. After lunch I pre-flighted the Viscount to give Jim some circuits. But he was too busy organising the flight safety conference to accept; which was a real pity. After that little episode I had great admiration for Mirage pilots which I still have to this day. Thanks a million Jimmy Treadwell. I understand you are still around.
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: ɐıןɐɹʇsn∀
Posts: 1,994
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am somewhat disappointed. I was led to believe that the firies covered that thing with so much foam that the only thing recognisable was the fin.
The Mirage was a death trap tbh. Australia purchased 115 aircraft, 39 crashed, 22 ejections, 20 pilots injured and 14 pilots killed.
The Mirage was a death trap tbh. Australia purchased 115 aircraft, 39 crashed, 22 ejections, 20 pilots injured and 14 pilots killed.
Yes, The best hour of my life was in the back seat of 77 Sqn's A3-116 on 24th January 1980. An engine air test flying up to 46,000' and through Mach 1. Then low level aerobatics in the Myall Lakes area including beating up unsuspecting water skiers..
A "forced landing" practice at Williamtown was joining circuit at 12,500' which was perfect for 190kts over the piano keys.. Brilliant fun!
recceguy, I'd be interested in reading more information from you. I was at 3 Sqn Butterworth between 1981 and 1983 and did many trips to RSAF Tengah during that time. RSAF had Hawker Hunters and F5Es there and then. The RAAF Mirages simply had a massive advantage over them flying dissimilar air combat tactics (DACT).
A "forced landing" practice at Williamtown was joining circuit at 12,500' which was perfect for 190kts over the piano keys.. Brilliant fun!
recceguy, I'd be interested in reading more information from you. I was at 3 Sqn Butterworth between 1981 and 1983 and did many trips to RSAF Tengah during that time. RSAF had Hawker Hunters and F5Es there and then. The RAAF Mirages simply had a massive advantage over them flying dissimilar air combat tactics (DACT).
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Australia
Posts: 1,186
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am somewhat disappointed. I was led to believe that the firies covered that thing with so much foam that the only thing recognisable was the fin.
Australia purchased 116 Mirages; 100 singles and 16 duals. 43 aircraft were lost to attrition.
Whilst 14 pilots were very sadly killed, at least 7 others went on to clock up more than 3000 hours in them.
Whilst 14 pilots were very sadly killed, at least 7 others went on to clock up more than 3000 hours in them.
