PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Military Aviation (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation-57/)
-   -   7 little weeks of Sadness..... XV109 today (https://www.pprune.org/military-aviation/416801-7-little-weeks-sadness-xv109-today.html)

NutLoose 31st May 2010 10:14

7 little weeks of Sadness..... XV109 today
 
Posted over on the Flypast Forums, but just to let you see her today, so sad. :sad:

What a crying shame, she was my favourite on the fleet and I had many happy memories of working on her. :sad:

More pictures by Plazz here..

VC10's at Brunty - Page 4 - Key Publishing Ltd Aviation Forums

http://i44.photobucket.com/albums/f3...C10/0077-1.jpg

http://i44.photobucket.com/albums/f3...C10/0071-1.jpg

http://i44.photobucket.com/albums/f3...C10/0079-1.jpg

http://i44.photobucket.com/albums/f3.../VC10/0066.jpg

minigundiplomat 31st May 2010 11:05

Seem to remember flying on VC10's in a similar state. Good aircraft in it's day, but time to go.

Hammer Head Too 31st May 2010 11:09

Not good, great !!:ok:

HH2

zetec2 31st May 2010 13:13

VC10
 
What a way to treat a lady !. PH.

c130jbloke 31st May 2010 13:15

Cannot see the difference between this one and half the others on the line :eek:

ab33t 31st May 2010 18:22

This is really sad !!!

kiwibrit 31st May 2010 18:41

My first productive tour as a very junior engineering officer was at Brize Norton Line Servicing Squadron - working on Belfasts and VC10s. The latter were so new that we found the reason No2 Doppler was having regular problems was that the 'earth' bonding to frame didn't work because of paint! I was very proud to be working on them.

Over 40 years ago.

Sad to see them being scrapped - but it's inevitable, of course.

Rigga 31st May 2010 19:36

Believe it or not - that's a really graceful end to a long career.

The old girl could have been "Guillotined" by a JCB and dumped in Skips.

November4 31st May 2010 19:52

Could well have been so very different

I flew on 109 as part of a MAMS team in Sep / Oct 1988 from Brize to Hong Kong and then two shuttles to Kathmandu. I think it was on that trip that that the Sgt (poss FS) Load Mistress ended up in the swimming pool, late at night, in Kathmandu...assisted a little by the Stewards and MAMS.

My trip on 109 was the one that could have been a different ending for her.

8 Dec 1988 109 was tasked to recover RM pax from Gardermoen when a Hercules went u/s. Gardermoen - Leuchars - Brize no problem except over, Birmingham a bang was heard from the wheel well. Apparently one of the main wheels had exploded and the debris had taken out the fuel lines to 2 of the engines as well as the auto pilot and hydraulic system. The crew managed to recover to Brize and the 50 or so RM and crew evacuated the aicraft via the enmergency slides. We later heard that this was the closest to losing a VC10 that the RAF had come.

8 months later though, 109 brough me home from a 6 month tour in Belize. Not sure if that was a good move or not as I got engaged not long after. But I suppose after almost 20 years of marriage....yes it was a good thing.

pma 32dd 31st May 2010 20:10

I think there are only 4 pilots (ie 2 crews)who landed a VC10 on 2 engines (real not sim assymetric). The story above is one. I might have had involvement in the other! Aug 02 and I think XV109 IIRC at BZN post 3 eng ferry. I'll have to check my logbook next week.

NutLoose 31st May 2010 20:27

Didn't Maggie go out to Washington on a Vc10, land in a Trident, set off back in a Trident and land back at Brize in a 1-11? and all the same aircraft.. ;)

On_The_Top_Bunk 1st Jun 2010 00:08

Not before time. Harsh but fair.

BANANASBANANAS 1st Jun 2010 10:23


I think there are only 4 pilots (ie 2 crews)who landed a VC10 on 2 engines (real not sim assymetric). The story above is one. I might have had involvement in the other! Aug 02 and I think XV109 IIRC at BZN post 3 eng ferry. I'll have to check my logbook next week.
'GD' by any chance??

Old-Duffer 1st Jun 2010 12:24

Sad but inevitable
 
The photos of XV109 remind me of a Beverley which had been blown up in the middle east and was lying at the side of the strip, looking so forlorn with its crew standing around.

The bubble caption has one of the crew saying: "How long to fix it, Eng?"

matkat 1st Jun 2010 12:25

November, I remember that incident clearly as I should because here is the whole story. The aircraft came into Leuchars and was seen in by myself (The VAS line supervisor at the time) and 2 others did a walk round and noticed a large "scalop" out of one of the tyres looked like if you had carved a slice out of it with a knife. I advised the FE of what we had seen and advised that as far as we were concerned it was U/S we proceeded to the mess for supper only to be told by radio that the aircraft was leaving we rushed back and sure enough the G/E was on the headset directing the start-up I spoke to him and also advised him that IMO the tyre was U/S and had to be changed he said no it is ok they subsequently left. I returned to the VAS office and wrote what I had seen/advised etc. in the diary and said to the other 2 to sign, we also had a movements team(4 people) from Leuchars who I had said to go and look at the tyre. We did not hear anything about what happened until sometime later approx 3 weeks IIRC this was conveyed to me from the board of enquiry that had been set up and who were to travel to Leuchars to interview me, at that the Captain said that he was unaware of my missgivings but this was refuted by myself and my team because when I advised the FE they were both together and the Captain then instructed the FE to check it out I also had my 2 lads as witnesses to the event. I was also advised that this was very close to loosing the aircraft and only caused by your crew, obviously I am very happy it turned out ok but I can tell you myself and 2 lads were extremely annoyed(put mildly) by the way your crew tried to implicate the 3 of us in this however there were just to many witnesses to coroborate what really went on, I have no idea what the outcome of the B of I was if you know please let me know.

NutLoose 1st Jun 2010 13:10

Wouldn't suprise me, reminds me of the one in Hong Kong that they noticed fuel leaking out of a wing, close inspection revealed a couple of inch crack in the lower wing skin, now these skins are rolled so all the metal grain runs in one direction for strength I believe, which means the crack can rapidly open like a zip...... so what did they do, they flew it back to the UK!!

BTW MAMS are movers and would be PAX not crew.

November4 1st Jun 2010 13:29

Nutloose...why the dig


BTW MAMS are movers and would be PAX not crew
as I can't see anywhere on here where anyone has claimed the MAMS were crew. MAMS teams were usually manifested as Support Crew just the same as the GE were but never Air Crew.

MatKat

Thanks for the extra details. As I remember it, the crew were also told in Gardermoen by the Norwiegians that the wheel was U/S.

NutLoose 1st Jun 2010 14:25

Wasn't meant to be an intentional dig or inferred to be, simply the line


by the way your crew tried to implicate the 3 of us in this
reads as if they were part of the crew,

"by the way the crew" would have distanced him from being part of them, does that make sense??

Sorry for any confusion, thats why I put about the movers to show that they wouldn't be part of the flying crew.

November4 1st Jun 2010 14:43

Thanks Nutloose

Just didn't want to descend into another mover bashing thread.

BEagle 1st Jun 2010 15:17

matkat, thanks for your account. When we of the superior VC10 tanker squadron used to visit Leuchars, we had nothing but good things to say about Leuchars VASF. Many a time on operational air defence detachments Big George and the rest of his happy gang would provide us with truly excellent assistance.

The actions of that 'shiny' crew are perplexing, to say the least. If you were so worried as to have such clear concerns about the aircraft's safety, the captain should most certainly have taken your advice and had the tyre changed. Bloody daft not to have done so, in my opinion.

Next time (I hope that there won't be one, of course), Flash call the tower and tell them that the aircraft taxying out has been seen to have a badly damaged tyre - and get them to call OC Ops Wg (or whatever silly title he now has...). No-one will ever criticise caution.

Pressonitis, a tyre explosion and failure of 2 LP fuel cocks as a result. They were very, very lucky.....

A VC10K3 once landed with 2 engines stuck at idle in the early days of the VC10K - it seemed that the stub wing drainholes had been blocked since delivery and water had frozen at altitude, effectively jamming the throttle controls which couldn't be moved after a long descent. A good job that the same fault wasn't also present on the other side....:eek:


All times are GMT. The time now is 13:04.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.