2 x Eurofighters + 1 x Apache
"Mildly" Eccentric Stardriver
OK Evalu8ter, I take your point, although boll*cks was a bit strong. My experience was back in the late sixties and the helos were unarmed. Basically Wessex v Hunter scenarios.
Herod,
Apologies old chap - I was a little 'refreshed' at the time! The problem as I often found was actually working the jets into a position where they could actually find us...including several times against radar jets. Now, if the FJs acquired the helos, and the RW crews were not trained in the correct tactics, then you're probably correct....the 2v2 Scout / Pucara fight in 1982 is a tragic illustration.
Again, sincere apologies.
Apologies old chap - I was a little 'refreshed' at the time! The problem as I often found was actually working the jets into a position where they could actually find us...including several times against radar jets. Now, if the FJs acquired the helos, and the RW crews were not trained in the correct tactics, then you're probably correct....the 2v2 Scout / Pucara fight in 1982 is a tragic illustration.
Again, sincere apologies.
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: New Braunfels, TX
Age: 70
Posts: 1,954
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
For whatever its worth, there were a few well documented actual jet vs helo engagements in the first Gulf War. The helos lost. Most were downed by missiles, but two helos were downed by the A-10's 30mm gun and one was hit (in flight!) with a 2000 lb laser guided bomb released by an F-15E. The helo disintegrated.
KenV,
Indeed - a Hip killed by A10s and a Hind fragged (literally.....) by a Mudhen. I had a pair of F15s simulate that on me once after we'd trashed every mx shot they tried....Neither RW crew were tactically aware, and were operating in hostile skies with little to no support or SA. Both kills were cued by AWACS. The LGB was used as it out ranged the AIM-9.
Far better to study is the Iran/Iraq war; hundreds of all sorts of engagements both FJ v Helo and Helo v Helo.
Sun - the course still runs. Happy days....
Indeed - a Hip killed by A10s and a Hind fragged (literally.....) by a Mudhen. I had a pair of F15s simulate that on me once after we'd trashed every mx shot they tried....Neither RW crew were tactically aware, and were operating in hostile skies with little to no support or SA. Both kills were cued by AWACS. The LGB was used as it out ranged the AIM-9.
Far better to study is the Iran/Iraq war; hundreds of all sorts of engagements both FJ v Helo and Helo v Helo.
Sun - the course still runs. Happy days....
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: west somerset
Age: 69
Posts: 38
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Probably the one mentioned in the NOTAMs last week, (I forget which day now) diagonal orange line running S.E. from Yeovilton to Blandford Forum, worded to the effect of "Air interception exercise involving 3 aircraft of different types" hope this helps in answer to the OP.
Though during the time when the AH-58D armed Kiowa Warrior was about to be declassified after the return to Ft Bragg from the Gulf.....they were armed with MIM-32A Stinger. The AH-58D had replaced or supplemented the Nightstalkers A/MH-6 operating off the barges with SEALs on board during Pray Mantis / Prime Chance.
Rumor had it that the Stingers may have been fired against Iranian fighters according to Hans Halberstadt's Army Aviation (Presidio Power series pub circa 1989)
Were we not toying with Blowpipe / Javelin trials on Gazelle in the 80s but nothing came of fruition?
The 80s trials at White Sands with AH-64 firing an AIM-9L but it was not standard arm for the army but again during the Persian Gulf, the USMC armed their AH-1T then AH-1W with AIM-9L.
Cheers
Rumor had it that the Stingers may have been fired against Iranian fighters according to Hans Halberstadt's Army Aviation (Presidio Power series pub circa 1989)
Were we not toying with Blowpipe / Javelin trials on Gazelle in the 80s but nothing came of fruition?
The 80s trials at White Sands with AH-64 firing an AIM-9L but it was not standard arm for the army but again during the Persian Gulf, the USMC armed their AH-1T then AH-1W with AIM-9L.
Cheers
Oz,
I did say 'fast'...!
IMHO The Jag was the easiest FJ of the lot to beat in a RW; poor vision post merge, poor turning performance, no radar or IRSTS, only one set of eyes and a big-ish planform when (trying to) turn. Never looked comfortable at low speed (no pun intended), but then nor did the F3....Doubtless the HMD and ASRAAM combo (which I think the Indians got?) would have been a massive improvement. The fact is, to set up for a low level lay down attack requires the jet to acquire and maintain tally for a long time, and assumes the Helo doesn't do anything about it. If you can blanket an area with Frag then well done - but it's not as easy to do as it sounds and would require a large slice of luck for one jet with one or two weapons (unless you're plinking from ML with a LGB). When the -15Es did it to me they simulated 2x Mk84 per jet and I was over the water so maintaining either radar or visual padlock was a lot easier....
Great fun trying though......
I did say 'fast'...!
IMHO The Jag was the easiest FJ of the lot to beat in a RW; poor vision post merge, poor turning performance, no radar or IRSTS, only one set of eyes and a big-ish planform when (trying to) turn. Never looked comfortable at low speed (no pun intended), but then nor did the F3....Doubtless the HMD and ASRAAM combo (which I think the Indians got?) would have been a massive improvement. The fact is, to set up for a low level lay down attack requires the jet to acquire and maintain tally for a long time, and assumes the Helo doesn't do anything about it. If you can blanket an area with Frag then well done - but it's not as easy to do as it sounds and would require a large slice of luck for one jet with one or two weapons (unless you're plinking from ML with a LGB). When the -15Es did it to me they simulated 2x Mk84 per jet and I was over the water so maintaining either radar or visual padlock was a lot easier....
Great fun trying though......
I remember there was a plan to incorporate a RW exercise around Spadeadam/Otterburn during a Mallet Blow in late 80s.
With both the FJ and RW concentrating on other tasks it would have been interesting to see how much interaction (and kills) there was from the strike packages running into their targets.
To muddy the waters certain helos types would have been deemed as friendly and others as the opposition
I'm guess it got canned over lack of deconfliction!
With both the FJ and RW concentrating on other tasks it would have been interesting to see how much interaction (and kills) there was from the strike packages running into their targets.
To muddy the waters certain helos types would have been deemed as friendly and others as the opposition
I'm guess it got canned over lack of deconfliction!
"Mildly" Eccentric Stardriver
I'm guess it got canned over lack of deconfliction!
23rd May 1982, Shag Cove, West Falkland. I x Puma with wingtip vortices, I x Augusta 109A gunship with 30mm Aden and another Puma with 30mm on the ground.
They flew too low over an inlet and left a snail trail on the water. Mistake! The gunship escort then tried to run away instead of engaging me with his rockets.
And I used to be a helo pilot!!
Read it all in "Hostile Skies". !!
They flew too low over an inlet and left a snail trail on the water. Mistake! The gunship escort then tried to run away instead of engaging me with his rockets.
And I used to be a helo pilot!!
Read it all in "Hostile Skies". !!
Join Date: Aug 2014
Location: New Braunfels, TX
Age: 70
Posts: 1,954
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
KenV,
Indeed - a Hip killed by A10s and a Hind fragged (literally.....) by a Mudhen. I had a pair of F15s simulate that on me once after we'd trashed every mx shot they tried....Neither RW crew were tactically aware, and were operating in hostile skies with little to no support or SA. Both kills were cued by AWACS. The LGB was used as it out ranged the AIM-9.
Indeed - a Hip killed by A10s and a Hind fragged (literally.....) by a Mudhen. I had a pair of F15s simulate that on me once after we'd trashed every mx shot they tried....Neither RW crew were tactically aware, and were operating in hostile skies with little to no support or SA. Both kills were cued by AWACS. The LGB was used as it out ranged the AIM-9.