PDA

View Full Version : Congress to legalise sabotage


ORAC
25th July 2002, 19:51
CNN/Reuters:

WASHINGTON (Reuters) -- Media companies would be allowed to sabotage Napster-style networks to prevent songs, movies and other copyrighted materials from being swapped over the Internet, under a bill introduced in Congress Thursday.

The bill would permit recording companies and other copyright holders to hack onto networks to thwart users looking to download free music, and would protect them from lawsuits from users.

Although Congress has little time to debate the bill before the August recess, sponsor Rep. Howard Berman, a California Democrat, said the measure was necessary because the decentralized systems were impossible to shut down.

"No legislation can eradicate the problem of peer-to-peer piracy. However, enabling copyright creators to take action to prevent an infringing file from being shared via P2P (peer-to-peer) is an important first step," Berman said in remarks on the floor of the House.

The bill does not specify what measures copyright owners could take to foil online song swapping, but does impose some limits on their efforts.

Rampant piracy?
Copyright owners would only be able to stop the trading of their own songs, and would be required to notify users and the Justice Department when they took action.


Overzealous companies could face a government ban and lawsuits from users who suffered economic harm.

The recording industry blames rampant online piracy for a decline in CD sales last year and has prosecuted online networks aggressively.

While the industry succeeded in shutting down the pioneer Napster service last summer, other, less centralized networks such as KaZaA and Morpheus continue to attract millions of users.
CNN (http://www.cnn.com/2002/TECH/industry/07/25/copyright.reut/index.html)

Evo7
26th July 2002, 07:45
The bill would permit recording companies and other copyright holders to hack onto networks


Wow, I can hardly wait. Maybe the RIAA are archiving my PPRuNe posts - they are my original work, right? Better get out my l33t h@xx0r T-shirt and go take a look, and when the FBI come a-knocking I'll tell them that it's fine because Howard Berman says I can do it. How cool is that? :)

The reality, of course, sucks. "Trusted" computing means that they aren't even going to have to hack - hell, we trust them to come take a look that we're clean, right?

Chaffers
26th July 2002, 09:08
This is not good news. However I don't quite understand how far they can take this.

to take action to prevent an infringing file from being shared via P2P

Ok so the copyright owning corporation can attack the p2p network; but how exactly does one hack a p2p network? Denial of service is barely feasable; with 1.5 million users currently online merely on the KazaA network it would be next to impossible to target indivdual machines. Even if the network(s) currently have central servers it wil be quite possible to start a p2p network that does away with these entirely, leaving the corporations chasing after whichever users decide to log on as a 'node' for a matter of hours?

Depending upon how far they decide to take this I an see Linux coming into its own :cool: .

Evo7
26th July 2002, 09:15
Depending upon how far they decide to take this I an see Linux coming into its own


The problem is going to be the hardware. If Linux isn't a trusted operating system - and if it offers you freedom, it isn't going to be - then the hardware will refuse to run it.

PPRuNe Towers
26th July 2002, 16:47
For one heady, nay, giddy moment I thought Congress were legalising Cabotage:D :D

ORAC
26th July 2002, 17:34
Someone I know has equated this with the Letters of marque which used to be given to sailors like Drake.

What happens when they screw up and take down or damage legal systems? Can they be sued? What will the penalty be?

They need also beware. I tend to think the best hackers are on the other side and will retaliate against the companies in kind....

Chaffers
27th July 2002, 03:59
And that is sooo true that I almost feel sorry for any poor misguided multi-national that tries it......

Send Clowns
1st August 2002, 00:00
I'm sure the decline in CD sales (and the spread of piracy) is nothing to do with the cartel of record labels overpricing their product, selling it at a higher price than previous technology despite CDs being far cheaper to manufacture and distribute :rolleyes: