PDA

View Full Version : Canadian Lanc looking at a $180,000 Cdn bill for the engine.


NutLoose
22nd Sep 2014, 22:08
The one that failed, they have a loaner off the BBMF in at the moment and I think that's on power by the hour.

Details
Hamilton Lancaster engine repair to cost $180K - Hamilton - CBC News (http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/hamilton-lancaster-engine-repair-to-cost-180k-1.2774375)

If you are interested Lancaster Engine Overhaul Appeal

http://www.warplane.com/about-cwhm/donate/donationsform.aspx

NutLoose
22nd Sep 2014, 22:33
Me too :ok:

WildRover
22nd Sep 2014, 23:39
Also donated.

Dysonsphere
23rd Sep 2014, 06:51
Thought the engine came from the set of 4 for "Just Jane"

camelspyyder
23rd Sep 2014, 06:56
Cant confirm that Dyson, but BBC news report that LAHC East Kirby have made a big donation for Vera's engine rebuild.

Tiger_mate
23rd Sep 2014, 07:23
My understanding is that the team at East Kirby offered an engine but in the end the one actually used came from BBMF. I have also heard that the hire cost (per flying hour) is to whatever degree down to it being crown property and therefore under the eyes of beancounters. Ie No goodwill freebies.

There was a time not too long ago .............

davydine
23rd Sep 2014, 07:46
As a matter of interest does anyone know if the damaged engine is repairable? Also, is there a ready supply of Merlin engines available, I know that there are a number of companies restoring heritage aircraft, but one would assume that the engines are a dwindling resource?

Dysonsphere
23rd Sep 2014, 07:51
Someone was working building brand new merlins I gather the main problem is the block itsself just about every other part is made already. ( it might be the type of metal used is nolonger about)

emeritus
23rd Sep 2014, 08:26
Want something to have a cry over?

Back in the late 50's in Aust a brand new Merlin, zero hours , straight off the test bench, inhibited and crated could be had for 10 Pounds !!

Actually saw a receipt from the Dept of Supply. Same file had a rec for 250 Pounds for 1 mustang. 900 hrs TT.

Emeritus:{

golamv
23rd Sep 2014, 09:42
BLACKPOOL, United Kingdom – The pilot taking Canada’s last flying Second World War heavy bomber home across the Atlantic Ocean on Tuesday has “absolute confidence” in the 69-year-old Avro Lancaster’s ability to make the journey after borrowing an engine from the Royal Air Force to replace one that had an oil leak that left the Canadian aircraft trailing smoke at the end of a flight earlier this month.

“If I was not 100 per cent confident, we would not attempt this. I don’t want anything happening to Vera,” the pilot, 68-year-old Leon Evans, said, referring to the four-engine propeller airplane by her nickname. “We are not going to put it into conditions that could compromise that safety. . . . We will not run the risk of landing on runways that are ice-covered or with severe crosswinds or low (cloud) ceilings.”

ttp://www.ottawacitizen.com/news/Canadian+Lancaster+aircraft+prepares+journey+home+from+trium phal+trek/10225807/story.html

langleybaston
23rd Sep 2014, 10:37
yesterday's D tel., in addition to all its many sins ["my wife has it for the crossword"] said Vera was "shipped" to UK.

And they pay these bastard reporters?

Background Noise
23rd Sep 2014, 11:57
The supercharger broke - but bits went into the engine.

Motleycallsign
23rd Sep 2014, 13:19
Superb departure flypasts this morning over Lincs bases complete with fighter escort. I guess that was the end on an (V)era. Apologies pun intended.......Nice to hear that the LincsLanc Assoc has donated some monies towards the engine rebuild; all we need now is a lottery fund donation to get Just Jane into the air.

mmitch
23rd Sep 2014, 15:38
Just the carriage to send the Merlins back to their owners will cost a bit.
Surely the RCAF or the RAF have a transport plane with space?
I believe Retro Track and Air (who rebuild the BBMF engines) are looking at
the damage.
mmitch.

NutLoose
23rd Sep 2014, 15:59
Yep, which is probably in part why they went with the BBMF engine as opposed to the Just Jane ones, Retro assisted in the component change over to make it compatible with Vera, one would imagine as they already do the overhauls for the BBMF and probably did the spare, they wouldn't want to be disturbing engines that are overhauled by another party as in Just Janes, which I think were done by Maurice Hammonds Eye Tech Engineering.

Pontius Navigator
23rd Sep 2014, 16:38
I was talking with one of the Canadian team 2 weeks ago. He said there were 78 new Packard Merlins in the States.

Mandator
23rd Sep 2014, 18:14
The donation from Lincolnshire's Lancaster Association had a deeper meaning than just a donation. From the website:


"Lincolnshire's Lancaster Association has presented the Canadian Warplane Heritage Museum - which brought the wartime plane over to England - with a cheque for 10,695 Canadian dollars.

Association Chairman, Ray Bainborough, said: "We wanted to say a fond farewell to the Canadian Lancaster and her crew, who have been hosted by the RAF's Battle of Britain Memorial Flight at Coningsby, by presenting the Canadians with this donation.

"The figure of 10,695 is very significant. That is the number of Royal Canadian Air Force servicemen who died while flying with Bomber Command in the Second World War. It is extremely important that we remember them and their sacrifice."

glad rag
23rd Sep 2014, 18:14
Just the carriage to send the Merlins back to their owners will cost a bit.
Surely the RCAF or the RAF have a transport plane with space?

Problem is it can't really be a NATO tasking :E:E:E:E

Agaricus bisporus
24th Sep 2014, 13:06
Just the carriage to send the Merlins back to their owners will cost a bit.
Surely the RCAF or the RAF have a transport plane with space?


20ft container trans Atlantic about £5000. Barely even significant.

smujsmith
24th Sep 2014, 19:47
I'm just an old, ex RAF Airframe fitter, who had the honour to refurbish PA474 in the early 80s at Abingdon as gang boss on the team. There's no way that there should be any costs accrued in this venture? The historic tour by Vera has paid for itself in encouraging visitors wherever the two have appeared together. There must be media pay back for flights, stories etc. I offer one sense of indignity to all of this talk of cost. In the 80s/early 90s I was an Aircraft Ground Engineer on our C130K fleet. On many trips to the USA and Canada, any breakdown was given the best support we could dream of. On many occasions I was able to keep the aircraft going rather than wait for "flown in" spares. I'm sure a "Canada trainer" could be arranged for a suitably empty C130J, which might return with a reciprocal load. If not, then the treasury really has cocked up our military aviation.

Smudge:ok:

GeeRam
24th Sep 2014, 20:02
I was talking with one of the Canadian team 2 weeks ago. He said there were 78 new Packard Merlins in the States.

And quite a few of them are sitting in original crates in Kermit Weeks engine store.

NutLoose
24th Sep 2014, 22:51
You mean like these, there just his Alison's

http://www.khs.at/fantasy/112.htm

http://www.khs.at/fantasy/fantasy4.htm

cessnapete
25th Sep 2014, 07:30
The RAF fly Calgary trips with the Voyager. Plenty of payload there for the odd Merlin or two. A quick tech stop enroute shouldn't be a big deal.

Motleycallsign
25th Sep 2014, 19:09
Don't think a Merlin on a pallet will go into the lower hold of a Voyager Cessna; no freightdoor upstairs either so probably a J or C-17 load.

hoofie
26th Sep 2014, 03:13
What keeps coming back to me is that surely with a little bit of corporate and government goodwill, the costs to the Canadians can be kept as low as possible.

The idea of them shelling out $180k seems a bit unfair. I'm not saying they should get it for free but I would imagine companies up and down the line can donate the freight, parts, some time etc. After all, it's a golden PR opportunity or is that wrong because it involves a machine of war, not orphans or kittens ?

rolandpull
26th Sep 2014, 10:26
Looks like four good engines right now. VERA is airborne out of KEF, eight hour leg to Goose Bay. Safe trip chaps.

Out Of Trim
26th Sep 2014, 16:33
motleyCallsign,

You obviously havn't been anywhere near the hold of an A330-200 (voyager) before then!

One Pallet could hold probably 10 Merlin Engines, and the A/C can carry at least 6 pallets plus a couple of Baggage Containers in the lower holds.

For size equivalence, you can fit a large car on one pallet! :O

NutLoose
26th Sep 2014, 17:16
She has dropped into Greenland for fuel due to high headwinds, quoted off a thread on Flypast

CWHM have just announced that the Lancaster has landed in. Greenland due to high head winds. They will refuel and intend to arrive Goose Bay, 6.00pm local.

knarfw
26th Sep 2014, 17:23
Oh good, I'll be able to pop home for some tea and crumpets before watching her come in.

NutLoose
26th Sep 2014, 17:29
:) I tell you what they have my respect, they are going to an airshow on Saturday on the way home..

Quote off the same thread

Charlie, there are arriving at Goose Bay tonight and intending to fly on to the Vintage Wings of Canada Airshow at Gatineau Airport, Ottawa, arriving 13.00 Sat afternoon. Night stopping there and flying on to Hamilton on Sunday morning.



.

NutLoose
26th Sep 2014, 17:32
Knarfw,

You can get updates here

https://mobile.twitter.com/CWHM

aw ditor
27th Sep 2014, 09:21
Is she home yet?

NutLoose
27th Sep 2014, 10:31
She is due home Sunday their time, she is doing a display Saturday their time at Ottawa, she is back in Canada (Goose Bay), the long worrying sea legs behind her.

knarfw
27th Sep 2014, 17:03
She has now left Goose Bay on her way to Ottawa. We were a bit worried last night as it was raining heavily and was dark when she eventually arrived.


Not the greatest photo but it really was quite miserable.https://scontent-a-lga.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-xaf1/v/t1.0-9/10696439_10152658310421293_2588844397043955545_n.jpg?oh=3a5e 7e4d8ed4c87ef6a372228ebc4bfb&oe=54CBCE39

clunckdriver
27th Sep 2014, 19:16
Is there really an "airshow" in CYND, no NOTAMS and not a sign of anything as we flew by, Vintage Wings doesnt seem to be doing much flying these days, will check to see if its meant to be on Sunday, if at all, mind you its perfect weather for an airshow today.

knarfw
27th Sep 2014, 20:19
The weather cleared at Goose Bay overnight. Here's VeRA departing for Ottawa flying over the old WW2 hangar on the old RCAF side. The tower is not the original btw. Thanks to my good friend Norma for letting me share her pic.https://fbcdn-sphotos-b-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-xpa1/v/t1.0-9/10359548_10153615772390190_2563554206864717522_n.jpg?oh=c1e0 dba990e807ad4202a70a08cdd167&oe=54BCDC07&__gda__=1418168593_eda1efda257e933ce37d771ba664895c

NutLoose
28th Sep 2014, 17:01
She is home!

https://twitter.com/intent/user?screen_name=CWHM

https://twitter.com/intent/user?screen_name=CWHM

And what a welcome home crowd!

Thank you all for an excellent visit.

condor17
2nd Oct 2014, 19:47
Hi guys , found this tonight .......................


Canadian Forces C-17 East Midlands Airport ? FighterControl ? Home to the Military Aviation Enthusiast (http://fightercontrol.co.uk//forum/viewtopic.php?f=16&t=104705)

maybe this was an RCAF ''Canada trainer'' via Castle Don , East Mids a/p ...not far from RR and BoB country ....Hope so anyway .

rgds condor .

NutLoose
2nd Oct 2014, 19:51
Yes still there today, rumour has it picking up some of the Lanc bits

ambidextrous
7th Oct 2014, 08:03
Dear PPRUNERS,


See link below to government website. It would be good if we could get to three figures from those of a like mind.


http://epetitions.direct.gov.uk/petitions/70437 (http://epetitions.direct.gov.uk/petitions/70437)


With fraternal greetings,
Ambi

Flash2001
7th Oct 2014, 14:26
Dundas St. W Toronto on the south side circa 65-66, a motorcycle/surplus shop whose name I disremember. Merlin for sale for around 500 bucks. Them was the days!

After an excellent landing etc...

Bollotom
7th Oct 2014, 15:57
Done. Good effort needed for a well deserved reward to our Canadian cousins. Expensive bit of kit but if it keeps one of our legends in the air. :cool:

Davef68
7th Oct 2014, 16:14
And what happens when the BBMF need a Merlin for PA474, but their spare has been given to the Canadians? Will they get the funds to replace it?

GreenKnight121
8th Oct 2014, 03:20
Sigh.

The broken Canadian engine was left in the UK under repair.

Either it is returned to Canada when it is fixed and the BBMF engine is returned to the UK - or it will become an ex-Canadian engine, and the BBMF will have a newly-repaired spare.

That was all part of the bill mentioned in the original post.

NutLoose
8th Oct 2014, 18:04
Would doubt that GreenKnight, the BBMF one is a Rolls Royce and the Canadian one is a Packard built motor, plus the BBMF know their engines as do the Canadians..


Plenty of spares about take a look at this little lot

http://www.51-factory.com/inventory.htm



.

GreenKnight121
19th Dec 2014, 04:05
Hamilton's Lancaster bomber's borrowed engine returns to U.K. - Latest Hamilton news - CBC Hamilton (http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/news/hamilton-s-lancaster-bomber-s-borrowed-engine-returns-to-u-k-1.2876758)

Hamilton's Lancaster bomber's borrowed engine returns to U.K.
Vera needed the British Rolls Merlin engine when one of its own quit during U.K. tour

CBC News (http://www.cbc.ca/news/cbc-news-online-news-staff-list-1.1294364) Posted: Dec 17, 2014 4:09 PM ET Last Updated: Dec 18, 2014 9:48 AM ET

Hamilton's Lancaster bomber Vera returned from its wildly successful cross-Atlantic tour three months ago with something borrowed. This week, it would be graciously returned it to its rightful owner.

A C-130 Hercules from the Royal Air Force U.K. arrived at the Canadian Warplane Heritage Museum Wednesday afternoon to pick up a Merlin engine it lent to Vera in the summer so the Canadian plane could fly home.

During an historic six-week tour in the U.K. with the only other airworthy bomber of its kind, one of Vera's four engines broke down. The Second World War-era plane was only able to continue its tour and then fly back to its home base at the CWHM with the help of a borrowed engine, a Rolls-Royce Merlin.

"We were grateful to get it. We are glad to see it go back to its home," said Al Mickeloff, marketing manager of the museum.

The crew will finish loading the engine into the C-130 Wednesday afternoon, and the plane is scheduled to depart Thursday morning at 8:30 a.m.

Vera's broken engine is still undergoing repairs in the U.K. and is expected to be returned to Canada in April.

An outpouring of support from both sides of the Atlantic has helped offset the costs of the repairs — totalling $180,000 — and some of the missed airshows while the bomber was grounded. The museum even had to redesign its website to accommodate donations in British pounds.