View Full Version : High wing v. low wing in a strong wind


peterh337
23rd Jun 2012, 13:31
Took this video yesterday.

I guess the wind was about 20G30.

The low wing aircraft is almost rock solid.



24Carrot
23rd Jun 2012, 13:38
Part of the effect may be due to the springy undercarriage. Actually, the springy undercarriage may even reduce the stress at the wing roots!

mad_jock
23rd Jun 2012, 16:12
Its partly because of the springy gear and partly to do with the geometry amplifier of having the wing tips further away from the geometric center of rotation of the aircraft while on the ground.

The low wing will have the wings nearly in line with the center and the high wing will be a couple of ft up from it

Pilot DAR
23rd Jun 2012, 18:34
The low wing aircraft is almost rock solid.

Yeah, and the other one wants to fly! ;)

mad_jock
24th Jun 2012, 07:44
To be fair it is half a ton lighter and another 5-10knts and it would be an insurance job it not being attached to the earth (note that a couple of concrete tyres wouldn't make a difference)

172driver
24th Jun 2012, 09:03
Yeah, and the other one wants to fly!

:D:D:D:D:D:D:D

Radar
24th Jun 2012, 09:21
Pilot DAR,

Love it :ok::ok:

piperboy84
24th Jun 2012, 15:49
looks like there is plenty room for a serious bit of wing down on final on the cessna

shortstripper
24th Jun 2012, 17:36
Last time I flew Gaybird she was white and green. I flew her into my old 250 yard strip with someone else; so I can assure you she gets off the ground pretty quick! :ok: