Pugachev Cobra
28th Apr 2010, 15:23
Hello PPruners...
I've been in a healthy discussion about the infamous S letter for the Equipment part of the standard ICAO FPL Form.
The issue is GA VFR aircraft pilots using S for essentially VFR flights, with their aircraft equipped sometimes only with VHF RTF.
If you read PANS ATM Doc 4444 Appendix 2, Item 10, it reads exactly as follows (bold highlighting by me):
"INSERT S if standard COM/NAV/approach aid equipment for the route to be flown is carried and serviceable (see Note 1).
(...)
Note 1 - Standard equipment is considered to be VHF RTF, ADF, VOR and ILS, unless another combination is prescribed by the appropriate ATS authority."
This seems to be a merely interpretation issue. If the route is entirely VFR with no radio navigation aids whatsoever, and all that is required is a radio, isn't the aircraft using standard equipment for the route to be flown?
The discussion was mainly based on some AIS facilities rejecting flight plan forms with the S equipment, citing that if it was only VHF equipped, the letter to be used was only V, and not S.
What can your experience say about this?
I've been in a healthy discussion about the infamous S letter for the Equipment part of the standard ICAO FPL Form.
The issue is GA VFR aircraft pilots using S for essentially VFR flights, with their aircraft equipped sometimes only with VHF RTF.
If you read PANS ATM Doc 4444 Appendix 2, Item 10, it reads exactly as follows (bold highlighting by me):
"INSERT S if standard COM/NAV/approach aid equipment for the route to be flown is carried and serviceable (see Note 1).
(...)
Note 1 - Standard equipment is considered to be VHF RTF, ADF, VOR and ILS, unless another combination is prescribed by the appropriate ATS authority."
This seems to be a merely interpretation issue. If the route is entirely VFR with no radio navigation aids whatsoever, and all that is required is a radio, isn't the aircraft using standard equipment for the route to be flown?
The discussion was mainly based on some AIS facilities rejecting flight plan forms with the S equipment, citing that if it was only VHF equipped, the letter to be used was only V, and not S.
What can your experience say about this?