PDA

View Full Version : UAVs or Aircraft


ORAC
6th Aug 2007, 22:18
I suppose here in the West, when you add in training, wages, housing, pensions etc etc, then UAVs are cheaper. Elsewhere?

DID: Bird Dogs for the Iraqi Air Force (http://www.defenseindustrydaily.com/bird-dogs-for-the-iraqi-air-force-03578/)

Iraq's air force has been very slow in getting to its feet. A handful of Seeker light observation aircraft with their distinctive bubble-shaped fronts, a few Comp Air light propeller aircraft, a couple of old, refurbished C-130E transports, and a handful of helicopters. A few Hawker Beechcraft King Air 350s have been ordered for transport and surveillance duties, and an RFP for armed counterinsurgency aircraft in is progress, but decisions to date have ensured that the Iraqi air force is still a long way from being able to secure Iraq's sovereignty and territorial integrity. Meanwhile, its primary duties remain troop/medical transport, light supply duties, and surveillance of roads and infrastructure.

That kind of surveillance doesn't require high tech, high-end aircraft. The USAF has been using F-16 and F/A-18 aircraft at $15,000 per flight hour, plus recapitalization amortization. In contrast, light propeller aircraft like Cessna's L-19 "Bird Dog" and O-2 successor worked very well in Vietnam. Their modern descendants can be outfitted with modern surveillance turrets plus "Mk1 eyeballs and ears" for a fraction of a fighter jet's acquisition and amortization cost, in order to do more or less the same ISR job. They'll also crash less often than expensive UAVs, and are more suitable for fledgling air forces. Specialty models like the Schweizer RU-38 Twin Condor even add acoustic silencing, plus more mission space for dedicated surveillance equipment.

The "Bird Dog" concept fits the IqAF's profile and support capabilities, which may be why Cessna Aircraft Co. in Wichita, KS has received a firm-fixed-price contract for $10.6 million. For about the price of a high-end Predator UAV system, this contract action will procure 18 Cessna C-172 aircraft (with an option for 10 more), logistics support services, and 1 year of spares for the Iraqi Air Force. At this time, $7.5 million has been obligated. Work will be complete December 2008. Air Force Materiel Command at Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, OH issued the contract (FA8617-07-C-6181).