BusyB,
So the entire contract is crap in your eyes because of a condition which may possibly effect 1 or 2 pilots? Also, when and where did a scope clause ever standup in court if the company declares a financial necessity? Or, maybe I should just ask you if these are your two top issues with CX today over EVERYTHING ELSE?
If the HKAOA allows individual complaints like the two you suggested to drive the HKAOA then the stalemate which we are experiencing will last for a VERY LONG TIME! There are many other more pressing issues IMO.