Originally Posted by Clandestino
They were not idiots in the medical sense but that they were ignoramuses is beyond doubt.
How could pilots be so ignorant to perform such a hazardous act ? IMHO, first: they have to be ignorant of aerodynamics and meteorology, second: gaps in their knowledge have to be filled by someone delivering his dead wrong message with great detail, patience and perseverance. Higher he be on the airline totem pole, it's easier for him to get the messages such as: "it will be blown off anyway" or "de-icing is useless but satisfies the authorities" across.
Unrealistic theory? Have a look at the last couple of pages on this thread.
I'm going to side-step the opportunity to respond in "like manner" ... as I've made the points that I believe are relevant and I'm quite comfortable in having done so. It's up to each reader to determine the level of competence and accuracy they wish to attach to each. I wish you all a comfortable coming week!