Fantome,
Like for those deeply insightful armchair experts who refute Justice Peter Mahon's finding out of hand, it would improve the prospect of maintaining reasonable, rational debate if they went out and polished the car. It is impossible to take seriously anyone who disputes the findings of carelessness, neglect and duplicity.
I do not believe anyone in this debate is refuting Justice Mahons findings out of hand. It is only one part, that the Captain was blameless that is being debated. Of neccessity that is concentrated on the decision to descend when and how he did.
To call everyone who disagrees with your opinion an armchair expert is about as productive, and useless, as me calling anyone who disagrees with my position a high chair expert who should be out pedalling his tricycle.